Where to sell · Clothing, shoes and bags
Where to sell costume jewelry online
Sell costume jewelry on eBay, where buyers search for signed makers and bid on mixed lots. Etsy takes costume pieces only when they are vintage, 20 years old or more, and not newer pieces bought to resell. Mercari suits a single signed brooch or necklace at a fixed price. Photograph the signature and describe the plating wear.
Best fits
- eBay
- Etsy
- Mercari
By Oleksandr Shaniuk, founder of Sellura. Updated 17 November 2026.
Marketplaces
The best places to sell costume jewelry
In order, with the reason for this product. Each row opens the generator on that marketplace.
Best for signed pieces and lots
Collectors search eBay by maker, and resellers bid on mixed lots by the box. eBay counts any piece on a base metal as fashion jewelry, even when it is plated with gold or silver, which is exactly what costume jewelry is.
“If the base metal is not gold, silver or a platinum group metal, the jewelry is considered fashion, even if the metal is plated with gold, silver or platinum group metal.”
eBay: Jewelry policy, checked 16 November 2026 Vintage costume pieces only
Etsy takes a costume piece as vintage once it is 20 years old or more. A newer necklace bought to resell is out, because Etsy does not allow reselling outside a few named cases.
“For an item to be considered vintage on Etsy, it must be at least 20 years old.”
Etsy: Vintage Items on Etsy, checked 16 November 2026 Single pieces at a set price
A signed brooch or a pair of clip earrings sells on Mercari with a few photos and a fixed price. Mercari asks sellers to keep unrelated brand names out of a listing, so an unsigned piece is never tagged with famous makers.
“We ask that you don't add a bunch of brand names and hashtags that aren't associated with the item.”
Mercari Help: Creating a listing, checked 15 November 2026
Not the place for costume jewelry
Amazon Handmade. The name suggests a home for jewelry, but Amazon Handmade is for things the seller made, and every product there is classed as handcrafted, hand-altered, hand-designed, repurposed or upcycled. A brooch from a flea market is none of those.
Source: Amazon Handmade, checked 16 November 2026
Specialist venues
- Antique malls and flea market booths. A booth sells a tray of brooches to people who want to pick them up, and the rent is due whether anything sells or not.
- Buyers who pay by weight. Some buyers take mixed costume jewelry by the pound for crafts and parts. Sellura cannot say whether their offer is fair.
Named so the picture is whole. Sellura does not write listings for them.
The arithmetic
What each marketplace keeps
On a $28.00 sale with $5.00 shipping charged to the buyer. The price is our example, not a valuation.
Our example price. Our example is one signed brooch sold for $28, with the buyer paying $5 for postage. The numbers are ours, picked to show the arithmetic, and say nothing about what your piece will sell for.
eBay
You keep $27.65 of $33.00
Fees $5.35: Final value fee (15%) $4.95, Per-order fee $0.40
Rates checked 15 November 2026 on eBay selling fees.
Etsy
You keep $29.41 of $33.00
Fees $3.59: Listing fee $0.20, Transaction fee (6.5%) $2.15, Payment processing (3% + $0.25) $1.24
Rates checked 6 October 2026 on Etsy Fees & Payments Policy.
Mercari
You keep $29.70 of $33.00
Fees $3.30: Selling fee (10% of price + buyer-paid shipping) $3.30
Rates checked 22 October 2026 on Mercari Help: Fees on Mercari.
What each row assumes
eBay category: Jewelry & Watches (except Watches, Parts & Accessories) (15% up to $5,000 · 9% over $5,000), checked 15 November 2026.
Computed by the same fee models as our calculators, for $28.00 plus $5.00 shipping. What the item cost you and the postage label are not in these rows.
The listing
What a listing for costume jewelry has to say
The facts a buyer filters by, the photos that answer the first question, and the order of the title.
State these facts
- Signed or unsigned, and the exact signature: Trifari, Monet, Coro, Napier, Sarah Coventry
- Base metal and finish: gold tone, silver tone, japanned, enamel
- Stones by material: rhinestone, glass, lucite, faux pearl
- Size: brooch width, necklace length, earring drop
- Fastening: pin and catch, clip-on, screw back, hook, box clasp
- Wear: plating loss, missing or darkened stones, green spots, a weak clasp
Photograph these
- The front on a plain background, lit so the stones show their color
- The signature, sharp enough to read, usually on the back or the clasp
- The back, where plating wear and repairs show
- Missing or darkened stones, close up
- For a lot, every piece laid out together, then the signed ones apart
Build the title in this order
- 1Signed maker, or Unsigned
- 2Vintage and the decade, if known
- 3Piece type
- 4Color and finish
- 5Motif
- 6Stone material
eBay · Title
Aim for ~75 characters (hard cap 80)
eBay's cap, our target, checked 6 June 2026
Etsy · Title
Aim for ~80 characters (hard cap 140)
Etsy's cap, our target, checked 3 September 2026
Mercari · Title
Up to 80 characters, use most of them
Mercari's form, not published, checked 22 October 2026
Check a title against eBay's limit · Every limit, with its source and date
Real output
Two listings Sellura wrote for costume jewelry
Shown as the generator returned them, with the form that was typed in. Nothing was edited.
Signed or unsigned: what the back of costume jewelry tells a buyer
Collectors turn a piece over first. A signature on the clasp or the back plate, such as Trifari, Monet, Coro, Napier, Sarah Coventry or Weiss, is what they search for, and a signed piece deserves its own listing. Copy the signature exactly as stamped and photograph it.
Unsigned does not mean worthless, it means unknown. Say unsigned, describe the quality you can see, and never put a maker's name in the title because a piece looks like their work. eBay files any stone of unknown type in Fashion Jewelry and asks sellers to make no claim that is not fully known.
Source: eBay: Jewelry policy, checked 16 November 2026
Check a title before you publish · eBay item specifics, field by field
Selling costume jewelry in lots or by the piece
Lots move a box of mixed pieces that would take months to list one at a time. Sort first: pull out every signed piece and anything with all its stones and a working clasp, and list those alone. The rest goes into a lot with an exact count.
Lots are bought by resellers and crafters, who judge them by what they can reuse. Show every piece in one photo, then the signed ones close up, and say whether you cleaned or tested anything.
- Count the pieces by type: brooches, earrings, necklaces, bracelets
- Name every signature in the lot, and say how many pieces are unsigned
- State the damage: missing stones, broken clasps, single earrings
- Weigh the lot if crafters are the buyers, and give the weight
Selling costume jewelry on eBay
List signed vintage pieces in Vintage & Antique Jewelry and newer ones in Fashion Jewelry. Mixed boxes have a Collections & Lots category under vintage, and a Jewelry Mixed Lots category under Jewelry & Watches.
eBay's jewelry policy asks sellers to disclose problems such as a broken clasp, and a buyer who receives an item not as described can return it even when you offer no returns. Call rhinestones and glass what they are, never gems.
Source: eBay: Jewelry policy, checked 16 November 2026
Selling costume jewelry on Etsy
On Etsy, costume jewelry is vintage at 20 years or more. Etsy's vintage policy lists explanations it will not accept as proof of age, and buying the piece at an estate sale or a yard sale is one of them. Date it from the piece itself: the mark, the findings, the materials.
Newer costume jewelry is a different matter. Etsy's seller policy does not allow reselling, apart from named cases such as craft supplies, so a bag of modern pieces belongs on eBay or Mercari.
Sources: Etsy: Vintage Items on Etsy, checked 16 November 2026 · Etsy Seller Policy, checked 16 November 2026
Selling costume jewelry on Mercari
Mercari works for one piece at a time: a signed brooch, a pair of clip earrings, a necklace in its original box. Leave famous makers out of an unsigned listing, since Mercari asks for no brand names that are not associated with the item.
Give the measurements and the fastening in the description, because the buyer cannot hold the piece. Mercari allows up to 12 photos, enough for the front, the back, the signature and every flaw.
Source: Mercari Help: Creating a listing, checked 15 November 2026
Questions about selling costume jewelry
Where can I sell costume jewelry online?
Should I sell signed costume jewelry separately?
How do I sell costume jewelry in bulk?
How do I sell costume jewelry on eBay?
Can I sell costume jewelry on Etsy?
Is fashion jewelry the same as costume jewelry?
Next step
Write the listing, then score it
Type what you have. Sellura writes the title, the description and the keywords to eBay's limits and scores the listing from 0 to 100.
What it costs
The score and the title are free on every generation, with no card. One credit opens the full listing. Starter is $15 a month for 25 listings, Pro is $24 for 65.
What Sellura does not do
It does not value your item, it has no database of sold prices, and it does not buy anything from you. It writes the listing and tells you how well it is built.
The first button opens the generator on eBay. The second scores a listing you already have.
Sellura is not affiliated with eBay, Etsy or Mercari.