Where to sell · Cards and collectibles
Where to sell Magic: The Gathering cards
Sell Magic singles worth a listing of their own on eBay, where players search by card name, set code and collector number. Run sealed boxes and colour-sorted lots of commons in a Whatnot show. A box of bulk goes best to a local player through Facebook Marketplace, handed over in person.
Best fits
- eBay
- Whatnot
- Facebook Marketplace
By Oleksandr Shaniuk, founder of Sellura. Updated 17 November 2026.
Marketplaces
The best places to sell Magic: The Gathering cards
In order, with the reason for this product. Each row opens the generator on that marketplace.
Singles by set and number
Magic players shop for one exact printing, and eBay's page for card game singles lets them filter by game, set, rarity, language and card condition. Collectible Card Games also has its own line in eBay's fee table, apart from the general one.
“Toys & Hobbies > Collectible Card Games”
eBay: Selling fees, checked 15 November 2026 Sealed product and colour lots
Commander players buy colour-sorted lots and sealed boxes in live shows, where a pack can be opened on camera. Whatnot's condition scale names Magic, and it tells sellers to take the lower grade when in doubt.
“If unsure between two conditions, select the lower condition.”
Whatnot Help: Whatnot TCG Definitions, checked 15 November 2026 Boxes of bulk, local players
Thousands of commons are worth more to a nearby player building decks than to anyone paying postage on a heavy box. The buyer looks through the box, pays in person, and the sale carries no selling fee.
“There is no selling fee for items that are picked up locally, or where the buyer pays the seller without using shipping and checkout”
Facebook Help Center: the Marketplace selling fee, checked 24 October 2026
Not the place for Magic: The Gathering cards
Etsy. Etsy takes resale only as vintage, which means 20 years old or more. Cards from the first sets of the 1990s pass that line, but almost everything in a modern collection does not, and Magic players do not look for singles there.
Source: Etsy's Creativity Standards, checked 15 November 2026
Specialist venues
- TCGplayer. A game card marketplace with a catalogue entry for every Magic printing, where many sellers list singles next to their eBay listings.
- A local game store. Buys singles and bulk over the counter. Many offer more in store credit than in cash, which suits a player who will spend it on new cards.
Named so the picture is whole. Sellura does not write listings for them.
The arithmetic
What each marketplace keeps
On a $35.00 sale with $4.00 shipping charged to the buyer. The price is our example, not a valuation.
Our example price. Our example is one foil single sold for $35, with $4 of tracked postage paid by the buyer. The figures are ours, picked to show the arithmetic, and are not a price for your card.
eBay
You keep $33.43 of $39.00
Fees $5.57: Final value fee (13.25%) $5.17, Per-order fee $0.40
Rates checked 15 November 2026 on eBay selling fees.
Whatnot
You keep $30.77 of $35.00
Fees $4.23: Commission (8% of the item price) $2.80, Payment processing (2.9% of the order + $0.30) $1.43
Rates checked 26 October 2026 on Whatnot Help: Whatnot seller fees.
Facebook Marketplace
You keep $35.00 of $35.00
Fees to you: $0.00
Rates checked 24 October 2026 on Facebook Help Center: Get paid for selling with shipping on Marketplace.
What each row assumes
eBay category: Comic Books & Memorabilia, Non-Sport Trading Cards, Sports Trading Cards, Collectible Card Games (13.25% up to $7,500 · 2.35% over $7,500 (per portion)), checked 15 November 2026.
Computed by the same fee models as our calculators, for $35.00 plus $4.00 shipping. What the item cost you and the postage label are not in these rows.
The listing
What a listing for Magic: The Gathering cards has to say
The facts a buyer filters by, the photos that answer the first question, and the order of the title.
State these facts
- Card name, set code and collector number, printed at the bottom left of recent cards
- Finish: non-foil, foil, etched foil, or a showcase, borderless or extended-art frame
- Language, since a Japanese or German printing is a different card to a buyer
- Condition on the players' scale: near mint, lightly played, moderately played, heavily played, damaged
- For older cards, the edition (Alpha, Beta, Unlimited, Revised) and the border colour
- For a lot: the count, the colours, the sets, and whether lands and tokens are in it
Photograph these
- Front and back of each single out of the sleeve, so foil curl and edge wear show
- The bottom left corner with the set code and collector number readable
- A foil tilted under light, where scratches and clouding show
- A lot fanned out colour by colour, with the count written on a slip beside it
- For a sealed box, every face of the wrap
Build the title in this order
- 1Card name
- 2Set name or code
- 3Collector number
- 4Foil or frame treatment
- 5Language, if not English
- 6Condition
eBay · Title
Aim for ~75 characters (hard cap 80)
eBay's cap, our target, checked 6 June 2026
Whatnot · Title
Aim for ~60 characters (hard cap 80)
Ours, checked 26 October 2026
Facebook Marketplace · Title
Aim for ~65 characters (hard cap 99)
Facebook Marketplace's form, not published, checked 24 October 2026
Check a title against eBay's limit · Every limit, with its source and date
Real output
Two listings Sellura wrote for Magic: The Gathering cards
Shown as the generator returned them, with the form that was typed in. Nothing was edited.
Set code, collector number and foil: identifying Magic: The Gathering cards
Many Magic cards are reprinted again and again, so the name alone does not tell a buyer which copy you hold. The set code and the collector number do. On recent cards both sit in the bottom left corner, with a letter for the rarity and the language code beside them.
Then the finish. The same card can exist as a regular printing, a foil, an etched foil and one or more alternative frames, each a separate item to a collector. Name the one you have, and photograph it tilted so the foil shows.
Magic: The Gathering cards as singles or as lots by colour
A single earns its own listing when a player would search for it by name. Below that line, cards are worth more together. Commander players build decks around colours, so a lot sorted into white, blue, black, red, green, multicolour and artifact sells better than the same cards in a jumble.
Count each lot and say what was removed. Basic lands, tokens and art cards fill a box without adding anything a player wants, so most buyers prefer them taken out.
Selling Magic: The Gathering cards on eBay
Singles go under Toys & Hobbies, Collectible Card Games, Collectible Card Game Singles. When we read that page on 15 November 2026, buyers could filter it by game, set, rarity, language and card condition, so those words belong in your listing. eBay calls an ungraded card simply raw, so the detail of its wear has to go in the description and the photos.
The oldest cards are where buyers ask most about authenticity. Show the back, the corners and a close look at the print, and say where the card came from if you know.
Sources: eBay: Collectible Card Game Singles, checked 15 November 2026 · eBay: Item condition by category, checked 15 November 2026 · eBay: Selling fees, checked 15 November 2026
Selling Magic: The Gathering cards on Whatnot
Magic shows on Whatnot range from pack openings to Commander singles sorted by colour. Whatnot has written its own grading scale for game cards, from mint through near mint, lightly, moderately and heavily played to damaged, with a cap on the imperfections each grade allows.
Say the grade aloud before each card runs and hold any flaw to the camera, as Whatnot requires. When a card sits between two grades, list it at the lower one.
Source: Whatnot Help: Whatnot TCG Definitions, checked 15 November 2026
Selling Magic: The Gathering cards on Facebook Marketplace
Bulk is where Magic sellers lose most time online. A local sale skips the postage and the packing: post the box with its count and colours, and meet the buyer at a game store where they can flip through it.
Facebook takes no selling fee when the buyer collects and pays you directly, so the whole price of the box stays with you.
Source: Facebook Help Center: the Marketplace selling fee, checked 24 October 2026
Questions about selling Magic: The Gathering cards
Where is the best place to sell Magic: The Gathering cards?
How do I sell bulk Magic: The Gathering cards?
How do I sell old Magic: The Gathering cards?
Should I sell foil Magic cards separately?
Can I sell Magic cards that are not in English?
Next step
Write the listing, then score it
Type what you have. Sellura writes the title, the description and the keywords to eBay's limits and scores the listing from 0 to 100.
What it costs
The score and the title are free on every generation, with no card. One credit opens the full listing. Starter is $15 a month for 25 listings, Pro is $24 for 65.
What Sellura does not do
It does not value your item, it has no database of sold prices, and it does not buy anything from you. It writes the listing and tells you how well it is built.
The first button opens the generator on eBay. The second scores a listing you already have.
Sellura is not affiliated with eBay, Whatnot or Facebook Marketplace.